?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

TV that Makes Me Angry

My new pet hate? "Medical Investigation", thursdays at 9.30. I wanted to like it, but it makes me full of rage. I am a rage bunny.

Take CSI (the bad parts) and mash it into ER (also the bad parts).

I find it insulting on an intellectual and a professional level. I mean, they took a swab, fed it into a computer, and then all these pictures of bacteria started flashing across the screen. A mix of EM images and Gram Stains. What the holy crap is up with that.

They actually used the line, "Now you're thinking like an epidemiologist".

And they have been mispronounciing bacterial species names.

Soon there are going to be legions of teenagers who think they know what it means to be a microbiologist/epidemiologist just because they've watched a TV show. Mark my words, this show is going to do to my field was Agent Dana Scully did to forensic science.

Comments

designadrug
Feb. 10th, 2005 11:41 pm (UTC)
As a scientist I had to stop caring, or else I never enjoyed anything I watched on TV. It was just too easy to pick holes.

I don't worry about the pronounciation (or indeed spelling). Many American scientists have trouble with "amine", "amide", "aluminium", "ephedrine" or even the last letter of the alphabet :)

Occasionally I'll gripe about something. My latest gripe when watching one of these shows (which arienmir can't seem to live without) was one founded of both knowledge and ignorance simultaneously.

Watching some forensic expert working with some irreplacable sample or other; I saw them sit in a lab alone, think for a while, take the whole thing and do a destructive test on it.

Now, I don't know what they do in real life, but since a murder investigation hinges on it I would think there would be lab notebooks being filled-out, SOPs looked-up, another expert signing-off on the work, some of the sample being retained for further testing etc. In short I'd expect some kind of operations standards similar to GLP/GMP.

But it passed :)

I try to laugh now, instead of cry. A few nights ago watching NCIS, I chuckled as the Goth Geek Gamer Grrl (GGGG) character pointed to the peaks on an MS and claimed each peak to be a different compound, and identified them by their peak mass alone. Apparently either the output of a GCMS isn't sexy enough, or wouldn't allow enough "sublime knowledge" to issue from the GGGG.

Luckily my chosen field is obscure enough, and unexciting enough to avoid dramatisation...although you shouldn't get me started on the molecular modelling at the beginning of "Hollow Man", or the modelling of DNA in "Jurassic Park".

Speaking of DNA, two of the biggest laughs I ever got out of pseudoscience:
"Mission To Mars" where a screen is showing an inaccurate computer rendering of about 12 basepairs of DNA found on the surface of the planet. One of the characters proclaims "That's human DNA!". From 12 base-pairs? Impressive.
"Species" where some scientist proclaims that the monster is very dangerous because "...it only shares 66% of our DNA!". And a Cauliflower only shares 38%...your point?

I agree about the lights though. At least they've progressed past erlenmeyers of funny-coloured liquids with chips of solid CO2 in the bottom to make them bubble :)

Sorry about the long post.

\\'
designadrug
Feb. 11th, 2005 01:32 am (UTC)
Actually the truly annoying part is that all it would take is one half-way decent scientific consultant on-set.
vanadamme
Feb. 11th, 2005 07:02 am (UTC)
Actually, as much as I hate to admit it the Americans are alright as far as their pronounciation of 'aluminum' goes. It was actually first named 'aluminum' but when the English got to it they changed it to 'aluminium' because all of the other metals in the same group ended with 'ium'.

At least, that's what Bill Bryson tells me.
designadrug
Feb. 11th, 2005 11:50 pm (UTC)
heh - my tongue was firmly in my cheek there buddy. You should have heard the crap I copped for my accent while I was living in St Louis.

The story I heard in the US was that when aluminium siding first became available there, an advert was put up in Times Square that misspelled it to aluminum and because that was the first exposure of the public to the material itself (aside from specialists like scientists and engineers) it kind of stuck.

When I was working tech support in the states I have honestly had someone ask me "Whats a zed?"
I laugh because it was *my* fault...when in Rome as they say.

I also have a friend who made a faux-pas at a job interview. It was Quebec, and he said Z-DNA as "Zee-Dee-Enn-Ayy" and the interviewer said "We use zed this side of the border" to which my friend replied "Oh - that doesn't sound very french!"

:)